Here is a question you might want to put on your list to ask potential knee replacement surgeons.

Are you using any devices that have been fast-tracked through the approval process via a 510(k) clearance by the FDA?

According to the website, “a 510(k) clearance is an approval shortcut maintained by the US Food and Drug Administration and allowable when a device is found to be substantially similar to a previous device and can be marketed safely.”  (my italics)

Consider the following story:

In January, 2013, 18 months after being approved, Stryker’s ShapeMatch Cutting Guide was formally recalled by the FDA with a Class I recall.

Get more information at the FDA recall page

This type of recall is the most serious of recalls responses that can be issued by the FDA. It is reserved for a situations in which there is a reasonable probability that the use of or exposure to the product will cause a serious adverse heath consequences or death.

Stryker’s ShapeMatch Cutting Guides were designed to be customized for each patient based on the surgeon’s pre-surgery planning parameters.

Instead, it was found that the cutting guides were not manufactured to the surgeons parameters perhaps due to a software glitch, which resulted in  mis-alignment of the implants.

As quoted from the the FDA:

The parameters of the manufactured cutting guides may not meet the surgeon’s pre-operative planning parameters entered via the web application. Additionally, Stryker Orthopaedics determined that another software defect resulted in the displayed parameters (e.g. depth of resection, angle of cut) not matching the cutting guides produced. This may result in serious adverse health consequences including joint instability, fracture,need for revision surgery and chronic pain and limitations of mobility.

According to,

Hip and knee replacement failures have been on the upswing since new products, many touting new materials and designs, were introduced to the market by way of FDA 510(k) clearance, but have failed up to live up to performance expectations.

Supporting evidence for that statement was not presented with that article but it bears looking into especially if you are a potential knee replacement consumer.

See the full article here

Michelle, PT
Michelle, PT

Michelle Stiles called "the no nonsense" therapist, by her patients, created a company called Cowboy Up Recovery after recognizing the bankruptcy of the present medical model. Too many people regard conventional medical wisdom as gospel, ignoring the subversive influences of Big Pharma and Big Medicine. She believes, Americans in general are being trained from an early age to defer to experts in numerous areas of life and losing the impulses for self-responsibility and self-reliance in the process. Over-diagnosis and over-medicating has become endemic. While thankful for the best miracles of modern medicine, she encourages people of all persuasions to listen to their bodies and seek out answers to maintain not just an absence of disease but optimal health. Her advice is: Cowboy Up, no one cares more about your health than you do.

    1 Response to "Knee Replacement Products-Aren’t They All Tested Rigorously?"

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.